Bourbon tastes best when paired with the right mixers. These mixers enhance flavors and create smooth, balanced cocktails.
Choosing the best mixers for bourbon can change your drinking experience. Classic syrups and bitters bring out bourbon’s rich, warm notes. Some mixers add sweetness, while others highlight hints of cherry, orange, or spices. Handcrafted options like Strongwater and Bittermilk offer natural ingredients and authentic taste.
Whether making an Old Fashioned or a Manhattan, the right mix adds depth and complexity. Easy-to-use cocktail syrups save time and make bartending simple at home. From maple pecan to bourbon barrel aged mixes, there is a variety to suit every palate. Discover how these mixers can make your bourbon drinks more enjoyable and flavorful.
10 Best Mixers for Bourbon
1. Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix
The Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix is ideal for cocktail enthusiasts and home bartenders who want to craft a classic Old Fashioned cocktail with ease and authenticity. If you enjoy hosting gatherings or savoring a perfectly balanced whiskey drink without the hassle of mixing multiple ingredients, this handcrafted syrup is perfect for you. Its convenient packaging and rich flavor profile make it a must-have for those looking to elevate their cocktail experience.
Pros:
- Handcrafted with organic Demerara sugar, bitters, orange, and cherry for authentic taste
- Conveniently makes up to 32 cocktails per pack
- Easy to use – simply mix with bourbon or whiskey
- Compact size with dimensions of 2.5″ x 4.8″ x 2.5″ and lightweight at 1.0 pound
- Craft cocktail mixer that saves time while maintaining quality
Cons:
- May not suit those who prefer customizing each ingredient individually
- Single pack limits quantity for larger gatherings unless multiple packs are purchased
The Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix stands out for its balanced blend of bitters, orange, and cherry flavors combined with organic Demerara sugar, creating a rich and smooth base that perfectly complements bourbon or whiskey. This handcrafted syrup simplifies the cocktail-making process without compromising on the traditional taste, making it ideal for both beginners and experienced mixologists. Its compact size and lightweight design make it easy to store or take on the go for events and parties.
Users benefit from the convenience of having a ready-made mixer that eliminates the need to buy multiple ingredients separately, reducing preparation time and effort. The ability to make up to 32 cocktails per pack ensures great value, especially for casual drinkers who want a consistent and flavorful Old Fashioned every time. Overall, this product offers a delightful combination of quality and convenience for anyone who appreciates a classic cocktail experience.
Bittermilk No.1 Bourbon Barrel Aged Old Fashioned Mix
The Bittermilk No.1 Bourbon Barrel Aged Old Fashioned Mix is ideal for cocktail enthusiasts and home bartenders who seek a sophisticated and all-natural way to craft classic cocktails. Those who appreciate the complexity of a traditional Old Fashioned but want to skip the hassle of mixing bitters and simple syrups separately will find this handcrafted cocktail mixer perfect for elevating their drink experience.
Pros:
- Made from all-natural ingredients for a pure and authentic taste.
- Handcrafted blend offers a more complex flavor profile than standard bitters and simple syrup.
- Convenient and easy to use, saving time in cocktail preparation.
- Compact dimensions (5.4 x 2.4 x 2.4 inches) make it easy to store and handle.
- Comes from a reputable brand and manufacturer, Bittermilk, known for quality cocktail mixers.
Cons:
- May be priced higher than basic cocktail mixers due to its handcrafted nature.
- Limited to Old Fashioned style cocktails, so less versatile for other drinks.
- Slightly heavier weight (1.03 pounds) compared to some mixers might affect portability.
The Bittermilk No.1 Bourbon Barrel Aged Old Fashioned Mix stands out because it combines the complexity of traditional bitters with the sweetness of simple syrup into one ready-to-use mixer. This reduces preparation time while maintaining a rich, nuanced flavor that enhances bourbon or whiskey-based cocktails. The bourbon barrel aging process adds a subtle depth and warmth, making each sip more satisfying and true to the classic Old Fashioned experience.
Additionally, the all-natural and handcrafted qualities ensure that no artificial flavors or additives interfere with the authenticity of the drink. This mixer is perfect for those who want bar-quality cocktails at home without the need for extensive ingredients or expertise. Its compact size and trusted brand name further make it a reliable addition to any home bar setup.
Strongwater Old Fashioned Craft Cocktail Mixer Sample 4 Pack
The Strongwater Old Fashioned Craft Cocktail Mixer Sample 4 Pack is perfect for cocktail enthusiasts who appreciate handcrafted quality and convenience. Ideal for those who enjoy making classic cocktails at home or on the go, this set is especially suited for bourbon or whiskey lovers seeking an authentic, flavorful experience without artificial sweeteners. It’s also a great gift for anyone who values travel-friendly cocktail solutions that don’t compromise on taste.
Pros:
- Handcrafted with natural ingredients, ensuring a high-quality cocktail mixer.
- Travel-friendly packaging makes it easy to enjoy cocktails anywhere.
- No artificial sweeteners, providing a clean and authentic flavor.
- Sample 4 pack offers variety and enough mixer to make 16 cocktails.
- Simple to use by just mixing with bourbon or whiskey, perfect for quick cocktail preparation.
Cons:
- Designed specifically for bourbon or whiskey, limiting use with other spirits.
- Sample pack size may not be sufficient for frequent cocktail drinkers.
The Strongwater Old Fashioned Craft Cocktail Mixer excels in delivering a classic cocktail experience with ease and authenticity. Each mixer is handcrafted, ensuring that every sip reflects the traditional flavors of a well-made Old Fashioned. Without any artificial sweeteners, users can enjoy a cleaner, more natural taste that complements the rich notes of bourbon or whiskey perfectly. The travel-friendly design allows cocktail lovers to bring their favorite drink wherever they go, whether it’s a weekend getaway or a social gathering.
This gift set is thoughtfully curated to provide a convenient yet premium cocktail-making experience. The four-pack sample offers a great way to try out the mixer or share with friends, making it an excellent choice for gifting. Its simple preparation method means even beginners can craft a delicious Old Fashioned with minimal effort, while seasoned mixologists can appreciate the quality ingredients and authentic flavor profile. Overall, the Strongwater mixer combines tradition, convenience, and quality in one attractive package.
Woodford Reserve Old-fashioned Cocktail Syrup
The Woodford Reserve Old-Fashioned Cocktail Syrup, infused with cherry, orange, and bitters flavors, is perfect for cocktail enthusiasts and home bartenders who want to craft authentic Old-Fashioned cocktails with ease. Ideal for those seeking convenience without compromising on quality, this syrup is a great addition for anyone looking to elevate their drink-making experience.
Pros:
- Authentic cherry, orange, and bitters flavor blend for a classic taste
- Convenient and time-saving alternative to mixing individual ingredients
- Produced by the trusted Woodford Reserve brand
- Compact and easy-to-store 6.75 x 2.75 x 2.75 inches dimensions
- Perfectly balanced sweetness and bitterness to enhance cocktails
Cons:
- May be considered pricey compared to generic cocktail syrups
- Limited to Old-Fashioned style cocktails, less versatile for other drinks
The Woodford Reserve Old-Fashioned Cocktail Syrup combines expertly crafted flavors of cherry, orange, and bitters that replicate the traditional cocktail profile. This makes it easy for users to prepare consistent, high-quality Old-Fashioned drinks without needing multiple ingredients or extensive bartending skills. The syrup’s precise flavor balance ensures each cocktail has the right depth and complexity.
Additionally, its packaging is designed for practicality, measuring just 6.75 inches in height and weighing 1.5 pounds, making it convenient for storage in home bars or kitchens. Manufactured by Bourbon Barrel Foods under the reputable Woodford Reserve brand, this syrup guarantees premium quality, allowing users to impress guests or enjoy a classic cocktail effortlessly anytime.
Strongwater Maple Pecan Old Fashioned Craft Cocktail Mixer
The Strongwater Maple Pecan Old Fashioned Craft Cocktail Mixer is perfect for cocktail enthusiasts who appreciate a handcrafted, rich flavor in their drinks. Ideal for those who enjoy classic cocktails with a twist, this mixer is designed for anyone looking to easily create professional-quality Old Fashioned cocktails at home, especially when paired with bourbon or whiskey. Whether you’re hosting a gathering or relaxing after a long day, this mixer simplifies the cocktail-making process without compromising on taste.
Pros:
- Handcrafted syrup with authentic pecan extract, sugar, and cherry for rich flavor
- Makes up to 32 cocktails, providing great value
- Easy to use—just mix with bourbon or whiskey
- Consistent taste every time
- Crafted by the reputable brand Strongwater
Cons:
- Flavored specifically for Old Fashioned cocktails—limited versatility for other drinks
- Contains sugar, which may not suit low-calorie or sugar-restricted diets
The Strongwater Maple Pecan Old Fashioned Craft Cocktail Mixer is thoughtfully crafted to deliver a unique blend of maple and pecan flavors, enhancing the classic Old Fashioned experience. This handcrafted syrup combines natural ingredients like pecan extract and cherry, which add depth and sweetness that complement the boldness of bourbon or whiskey. The mixer’s easy-to-use formula ensures that even beginners can quickly prepare a delicious, bar-quality cocktail without the hassle of measuring multiple ingredients.
Besides its flavor profile, the mixer offers convenience and value by producing up to 32 cocktails from a single bottle. This makes it an excellent choice for parties or regular home use. Furthermore, being a product of Strongwater, it upholds a standard of quality and authenticity that cocktail lovers can trust. Overall, this mixer is a smart addition to any home bar for those seeking to elevate their cocktail game with minimal effort.
Proof Syrup Old Fashioned Cocktail Mix
The Proof Syrup Old Fashioned Cocktail Mix is ideal for cocktail enthusiasts who appreciate classic flavors but seek convenience. Perfect for both home bartenders and professional mixologists, this handcrafted syrup offers a fast and easy way to create authentic Old Fashioned cocktails without compromising on taste. If you want to enjoy a traditional cocktail experience with minimal effort, this product is designed for you.
Pros:
- Made with real bitters and cane sugar for authentic flavor
- Handcrafted syrup ensures high quality and consistency
- Fast and easy preparation of cocktails
- Compact 16oz bottle, convenient for home or bar use
- Traditional Old Fashioned flavor that appeals to purists
Cons:
- Limited to Old Fashioned cocktail style, less versatile for other drinks
- Only one bottle size available, which may not suit all needs
This 16oz bottle of Proof Syrup Old Fashioned Cocktail Mix is carefully crafted by PROOF SYRUP, known for quality ingredients and attention to detail. The use of real bitters and cane sugar provides a rich, balanced taste that replicates the traditional cocktail experience without the hassle of mixing multiple ingredients. Its well-designed dimensions (Height: 4.5 inches, Width: 4.5 inches, Length: 10.5 inches) and light weight (1.0 Pounds) make it easy to store and handle in any bar setup.
Users benefit from the syrup’s simplicity and speed—just pour, stir, and enjoy a classic cocktail with the perfect blend of sweetness and bitters. This handcrafted mix not only saves time but ensures consistency in every drink, making it an excellent choice for gatherings, parties, or everyday indulgence. The traditional Old Fashioned flavor satisfies both novice and experienced cocktail lovers, delivering a delicious and authentic taste with every sip.
Bittermilk Bourbon Barrel Aged Manhattan Mix
The Bittermilk Bourbon Barrel Aged Manhattan Mix is perfect for cocktail enthusiasts who appreciate an all-natural, handcrafted approach to mixing drinks. Ideal for those who want to effortlessly create a classic Manhattan cocktail at home without compromising on quality, this mixer is a great choice for both beginners and seasoned bartenders looking to save time while impressing guests. If you enjoy the rich, smoky flavors of bourbon and want a convenient way to craft multiple cocktails, this product is tailored for you.
Pros:
- Made with all-natural ingredients ensuring a fresh and authentic taste
- Handcrafted mix that captures the essence of a traditional bourbon barrel-aged Manhattan
- Convenient and easy to use—just add whiskey to make up to 17 cocktails
- Consistent flavor profile every time, ideal for entertaining guests
- Compact packaging perfect for home bars or gifting
Cons:
- Requires adding your own whiskey, which may not suit those looking for a fully pre-mixed option
- Limited to Manhattan-style cocktails, less versatile for other drink types
- Higher price point compared to basic mixers due to handcrafted quality
The Bittermilk Bourbon Barrel Aged Manhattan Mix stands out for its dedication to authentic flavor and quality craftsmanship. By aging the mix in bourbon barrels, it infuses rich, smoky notes that complement the whiskey perfectly, elevating the traditional Manhattan experience. The mixer balances sweetness, bitterness, and aromatic spices, providing a well-rounded cocktail base that enhances the whiskey’s natural characteristics.
Convenience is a key benefit, as this mixer allows you to quickly prepare up to 17 cocktails without needing to gather multiple ingredients or measures. Whether you’re hosting a small gathering or enjoying a quiet evening, the product simplifies cocktail making while maintaining a premium taste. Its all-natural formulation also appeals to those who prioritize clean ingredients and artisanal products in their beverages.
Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries
The Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries are perfect for cocktail enthusiasts and home bartenders who appreciate a touch of elegance and quality in their drinks. If you enjoy crafting classic cocktails like the Manhattan or Old Fashioned, or if you want to elevate your desserts with a gourmet garnish, these cherries are an ideal choice. Made with award-winning whiskey, they bring a rich, authentic flavor that complements both drinks and sweets.
Pros:
- Infused with award-winning whiskey for a unique, rich taste
- Comes in a convenient 11-ounce glass jar for easy storage and presentation
- Perfect garnish for classic cocktails like Manhattan and Old Fashioned
- Enhances desserts with a sophisticated flavor twist
- Compact size with dimensions of 4.5 inches height and 2.75 inches width and length, weighing only 0.6875 pounds
Cons:
- Limited to specific cocktail styles; may not suit all drink recipes
- Premium quality comes with a higher price point compared to regular cocktail cherries
- Glass jar packaging requires careful handling to avoid breakage
The Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries stand out due to their infusion with award-winning whiskey, which imparts a deep, complex flavor that enhances the overall drinking experience. This makes them more than just a garnish—they become an integral part of the cocktail’s flavor profile. The 11-ounce glass jar not only preserves freshness but also adds a touch of sophistication, making it a great addition to any home bar setup.
These cherries are designed with the classic cocktail lover in mind, but their versatility extends to culinary uses as well. Adding them to desserts introduces a subtle bourbon essence that can transform ordinary sweets into gourmet treats. Their compact size and elegant black color make them easy to store and visually appealing, ensuring that every serving looks as good as it tastes.
Barsmith Old Fashioned Mix
The Barsmith Old Fashioned Mix is ideal for whiskey enthusiasts and home bartenders who want to craft the perfect classic cocktail without the hassle of mixing multiple ingredients. If you appreciate a well-balanced bourbon cocktail with a harmonious blend of sweetness, cherry, citrus, and bitters, this premium mixer is designed for you. It is also perfect for those seeking a non-GMO option to enhance their home bar experience.
Pros:
- Convenient all-in-one classic whiskey drink mixer with balanced flavors
- Made by trusted brand Barsmith with quality ingredients
- Non-GMO formula suitable for health-conscious users
- Perfect size with 12.7 oz bottle ideal for multiple cocktails
- Enhances the taste of bourbon cocktails with natural cherry, citrus, and bitters notes
Cons:
- Only available in a single 12.7 oz bottle pack
- May not suit those who prefer to customize their own cocktail mixes
The Barsmith Old Fashioned Mix stands out for its expertly crafted blend that captures the essence of a traditional old fashioned cocktail. The mix combines the perfect level of sweetness, the rich flavor of cherry, a hint of citrus, and aromatic bitters, allowing users to quickly prepare a high-quality drink. Its premium non-GMO ingredients offer peace of mind for those mindful about product sourcing and health. The compact dimensions make it easy to store and convenient to use for any home bar setup.
By simplifying the cocktail-making process, this mixer saves time and effort while ensuring consistency in every pour. Whether hosting guests or enjoying a quiet evening, the Barsmith Old Fashioned Mix delivers a professional taste that elevates your bourbon experience. Its versatility and quality make it a must-have for anyone looking to enjoy classic whiskey drinks with ease and confidence.
Woodford Reserve Bitters Dram Set
The WOODFORD RESERVE® BITTERS DRAM SET – FIVE PACK (10ML EACH) is ideal for cocktail enthusiasts and professional bartenders who appreciate the art of mixology. If you enjoy experimenting with flavors or want to elevate your home bar experience, this set offers a convenient and high-quality way to enhance your drinks with unique bitter notes.
Pros:
- Compact 10ml bottles perfect for sampling and precise mixing
- Variety pack of five distinctive bitters flavors to diversify cocktails
- Produced by the reputable Bourbon Barrel Foods brand, ensuring quality and authenticity
- Convenient for travel or gifting to cocktail lovers
Cons:
- Small bottle size may run out quickly for frequent users
- Limited availability depending on location
Each bottle in the WOODFORD RESERVE® BITTERS DRAM SET is crafted to complement a variety of spirits, especially bourbon and whiskey. The small 10ml size allows users to experiment with different bitter profiles without committing to a large bottle, making it perfect for discovering preferred flavors. The set includes five unique bitters, each adding depth, complexity, and aromatic balance to cocktails, enhancing both classic and innovative recipes.
Made by Bourbon Barrel Foods, the bitters maintain a high standard of quality, ensuring that every dram contributes authentic taste and richness. This set is not only practical for personal use but also an excellent tool for bartenders who want to offer their customers a sophisticated and diverse cocktail menu. Ultimately, this bitters set empowers users to craft memorable drinks with ease and style.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Makes Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix Unique?
Strongwater Old Fashioned Mix is handcrafted with organic Demerara sugar, bitters, orange, and cherry. It offers a balanced, rich flavor that complements bourbon perfectly. This mixer is designed to simplify cocktail making while maintaining authentic taste and quality.
How Does Bittermilk No.1 Enhance Bourbon Cocktails?
Bittermilk No. 1 is a bourbon barrel-aged old fashioned mix that adds depth and complexity. It combines natural ingredients, making it richer than traditional bitters and simple syrup. This mixer brings a craft cocktail experience to your bourbon drinks.
Can I Travel With Strongwater Old Fashioned Sample Pack?
Yes, the Strongwater Old Fashioned Sample Pack is travel-friendly and contains no artificial sweeteners. It makes 16 cocktails, perfect for on-the-go bourbon lovers who want quality mixers anywhere.
What Flavors Are In Woodford Reserve Old-fashioned Syrup?
Woodford Reserve Old-Fashioned Syrup features cherry, orange, and bitters flavors. It is crafted to complement bourbon, enhancing the classic old fashioned cocktail with a smooth, balanced taste.
Why Choose Proof Syrup For Old Fashioned Cocktails?
Proof Syrup uses real bitters and cane sugar for a traditional old fashioned flavor. It’s handcrafted, fast, and easy to use, making it ideal for delicious bourbon cocktails at home.
How Do Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries Improve Cocktails?
Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries are made with award-winning whiskey, perfect for garnishing old fashioneds or Manhattans. They add sweetness and a premium touch to bourbon cocktails and desserts.
Conclusion
Choosing the right mixer can truly enhance your bourbon experience. These mixers offer a range of flavors, from classic bitters to sweet maple pecan and cherry blends. Whether you prefer a traditional Old Fashioned or a smooth Manhattan, the options here make mixing easy and enjoyable.
Many are handcrafted with natural ingredients, giving your drink a fresh, authentic taste. Using quality mixers can bring out the best in your bourbon without needing complex recipes. Remember, simple combinations often create the most satisfying drinks. Try different mixers to find the perfect balance that suits your taste.
With these choices, your bourbon cocktails will be flavorful and satisfying every time. Enjoy the process and savor each sip. Great mixers turn good bourbon into a great drink. Cheers to discovering your favorite bourbon mix today!